| 
 News
       

 Check This!
       

 Blog
       

 Blog
     

 Blog
     

 Don't average categorical or ordinal data!
Location: BlogsZen and the art of monitoring & evaluation    
Posted by: pcrawford Thursday, April 24, 2008

A surprisingly common mistake that is made with the analysis and interpretation of M&E data is to try to treat categorical or ordinal data as though it is quantitative data (i.e. interval or ratio data).  This is simply wrong.  It is bad numeracy!

First some background...

Categorical data (also called 'nominal data') describes an 'exclusive category'.  For example, consider a survey question:

What pets do you own: a) dog; b) cat; c) goldfish; d) none

These are categorical responses.  You either do or do not own a cat. 

Ordinal data is the same as categorical data, except that the order of the responses matters.  Consider a survey question:

How do you feel today: a) lousy; b) ok; c) great; d) never better

These are ordinal responses because most people would agree that they represent a progression of feelings.  BUT, the difference between the states is debatable.  My 'gap' between 'lousy' and 'ok' may be different to your gap between 'lousy' and 'ok'.  And furthermore, how I interpret the gap between 'lousy' and 'ok' today may be different to how I interpret it tomorrow!  But I will always agree that 'lousy' is worse than 'ok'.

Now to the common error...

For the sake of convenience, people often 'code' the responses in surveys with numbers, such as: 1) lousy; 2) ok; 3) great; 4) never better.  Then the tempation arises, to start manipulating the data quantitatively.  For example, someone might try to average all of the responses to the question "how do you feel today" and conclude that because the number '3.4' can be derived, that the 'average' feeling is "great".

The way to check that your analysis is sensical, is to substitute the numbers for letters and see if you can still perform the same analysis, and derive the same conclusion.  For instance:

A + B / 2 = ?? 

Or

'Cat' + 'Dog'/2 = ??

Or

'lousy' + 'ok' = ??

Useful analysis of categorical and ordinal data includes:

  • Mode: what is the most frequent response (e.g. more people answered 'dog' than any other response)
  • Frequency: the percentage of respondents that chose 'goldfish'; or the distribution of frequencies for all responses
  • Crosstabulation: e.g. 'of those people that said they own a "dog", what proportion said that they felt "never better"?'

 

 

Permalink |  Trackback

Comments (12)   Add Comment
Re: Don't average categorical or ordinal data!    By Anonymous on Thursday, September 25, 2008
what about using the median for analysis of ordinal data? Would this be a more useful tool than the mode, and if so, why?

Re: Don't average categorical or ordinal data!    By Anonymous on Thursday, September 25, 2008
what about using the median for analysis of ordinal data? Would this be a more useful tool than the mode, and if so, why?

Re: Don't average categorical or ordinal data!    By Anonymous on Wednesday, September 02, 2009
Median is helpful - but not very...

The problem with median in ordinal-polytomous responses is that it won't give you much to compare - let's say you have three questions: one for gold-fish owners, one for dog owners, and one for cat owners - and each of these groups will be asked "How do you feel today?"...

I can assure you that the median will not help you much with establishing any differences between these groups. An average will, although it is strictly speaking "forbidden" (in a mathematical sense).

Or does anybody see any other possibility?

p90x    By Anonymous on Thursday, May 27, 2010
The cost for P90X is about three months of a paid gym membership but you get to keep the program forever,
P90x . You can try many of the online sites, but it will be the same as buying from the company or a Beachbody Coach.
Make sure you are getting original DVD's. People are selling copies all over. The problem is how long will they last, P90x workout ,and you truly need the exercise and nutrition guide to even follow the program.
You can go to any site or you can go and click on products. P90x dvd You can order directly from the site.
You love a challenge,insanity and you don’t mind working out on a pool of your own sweat, you might just be crazy enough for the Insanity Workout.
The extreme total body conditioning program that delivers mind blowing results in record time,Insaniy DVD.注册香港公司香港公司注册




p90x dvd    By Anonymous on Monday, June 14, 2010
P90x UPDATE – December 29, 2009. P90x dvd Over the accomplished year or so we accept gotten a lot of questions about this column and it has generated a lot of attention.
P90x workout One above development back we Rev Abs originally did this column was the addition of Shakeology Rev Abs Workout to the Beachbody band of supplements. Shakeology is harder to ascertain in the P90X Nutrition Plan.
Rev Abs dvd At 140 calories with 15g of rosetta stone protein and 19g of carbs (Greenberry) or 17g of protein rosetta stone reviews and 17g of carbs (Chocolate) it is not absolutely a abounding insanity dvd confined of either. With Beachbody’s advice,insanity
insanity workout we accept characterized it as a snack. 香港公司注册 Agenda that if you add items into the agitate and 注册香港公司 access the calories, it can calmly be a bifold snack, rather than a individual snack.
mbt shoes on sale A lot of humans like to add mbt sale bake-apple to the greenberry and mbt chapa things like almond adulate and bananas mbt professional shoes to the chocolate. mbt shuguli gtx If you do that, yield a minute and attending up the caloric ethics mbt womens shoes of your additions and clue them accordingly.
mbt shoes online We accept adapted the Excel mbt chapa azul certificate beneath to reflect this mbt usa change. Also, mbt tunisha sale we wish to point out that the mbt women's Results and Recovery Formula is aswell mbt women's chapa appropriately tracked as a snack. In that case it is a bifold snack.
mbt shoes clearance sale

mbt women's shoes We aswell capital to action our admonition mbt chapa white with your P90X journey.
mbt on sale If you are new to P90X, alpha with the mbt shoes for sale video beneath and again move through the post, mbt shoes sale mens shoes including the comments.
mbt tembea minkIt will yield a while, mbt's on sale but it will be account it. You’ll buy mbt shuguli accomplishment this column with a mbt chapa women's complete compassionate of why the plan mbt clearance works the way it does,
mbt denim and how to accomplish mbt help us to keep magento healthy .the a lot of of it. mbt sport shoes We are Team Beachbody Coaches and allowance humans with programs like P90X is what we do.
mbt tataga denim . If you would like to accept us drillmaster you through mbtsale amuse acquaintance me HERE, and we’ll accord you instructions shoes sale on how to accomplish that happen.
about mbt chapa shoes There is no amount to you for this affairs or our services, compare cheap mbt tataga but it is important for us to be assigned as your Drillmaster karl mueller mbt shoes in adjustment to accommodate mbt chapas you with advice,
mbt lami birch abutment and motivation. mbt lami shoes Also, analysis out our bulletin lath association at mbt m.walk shoes. Good luck and we attending advanced to audition from you.mbt on line

mbt online UPDATE – May 16, 2009. mbt sale online review We accept mbt sales on line adapted this column to cover a video mbt shoe insurance discussing the assets mbt shoes sales independent below.
mbt shoes usa .One key affair to agenda is that the circadian mbt shoes,discount mbt shoes,mbt shoes cheap,mbt walking shoes,mbt shoes sale trackers on the spreadsheet beneath mbt tunisha black. represent a mid-range in the assorted “Levels” of the program.
mbt women's m walk You will charge mbt womens lami to adapt the spreadsheet to your needs. mbts This is one acumen why we absitively to accomplish it an excel document, original korean walking shoes rather than a PDF.
sale mbt Amuse watch the video aboriginal and again use the resources.shoes on sale

Re: wholesale    By Anonymous on Tuesday, June 22, 2010
korean mbt shoes
m walk mbt
mbt all white shoes
mbt all white sneakers
mbt beach
mbt beach shoes
mbt chapa gtx price
mbt chapa gtx women
mbt chapa gtx women shoe
mbt chapa gtx womens
mbt chapa white woman
mbt faq
mbt m walk womens
mbt m.walk black
mbt m.walk shoes black
mbt m.walk women's shoes

Re: Don't average categorical or ordinal data!    By Anonymous on Monday, July 05, 2010
gucci
gucci handbags
gucci wallets
gucci bags
gucci handbags
Louis Vuitton Wallet
Louis Vuitton Shoes
Louis Vuitton Handbags
Louis vuitton bags
louis vuitton handbags
louis vuitton handbags
louis vuitton wallet
louis vuitton wallet
louis vuitton handbag
Christian Louboutin Boots

louis vuitton wallet
louis vuitton handbags
louis vuitton handbag
louis vuitton bag
louis vuitton handbags
louis vuitton wallet
louis vuitton handbags
louis vuitton bags
louis vuitton shoes
fendi handbags
fendi bags xfszyychi

Re: Don't average categorical or ordinal data!    By Anonymous on Tuesday, July 20, 2010
Baltimore Ravens Jerseys
Tennessee Titans Jerseys
San Francisco 49ers Jerseys
Carolina Panthers Jerseys
Cincinnati Bengals Jerseys
Cleveland Browns Jerseys
Jacksonville Jaguars Jerseys
Arizona Cardinals Jerseys
Atlanta Falcons Jerseys
St Louis Rams Jerseys
Buffalo Bills Jerseys
Dallas Cowboys Jerseys
Houston Texans Jerseys
Indianapolis Colts Jerseys
Minnesota Vikings Jerseys
New Orleans Saints Jerseys
Oakland Raiders Jerseys
New York Jets Jerseys
Pittsburgh Steelers Jerseys
Seattle Seahawks Jerseys
Chicago Bears Jerseys
Denver Broncos Jerseys
Detroit Lions Jerseys
Green Bay Packers Jerseys
Kensas City Chiefs Jerseys
Miami Dolphins Jerseys
New England Patriots Jerseys
New York Giants Jerseys
Philadelphia Eagles Jerseys
San Diego Chargers Jerseys
Tampa Bay Buccaneers Jerseys
Washington Redskins Jerseys
LeBron James Heat Jersey
LeBron James Jersey

UGG Classic Tall Boots    By Anonymous on Tuesday, July 27, 2010
UGG Classic Tall Boots,UGG Boots Classic Tall,UGG Boots 5815
UGG Bailey Button Bomber

lv    By Anonymous on Wednesday, July 28, 2010
if you want to buy Burberryfor sale
high quality of Burberry Handbags
beautiful Burberry Scarvesfor discount
As a top luxury consumablelouis vuitton handbags louis vuitton handbags
louis vuitton bags louis vuitton handbags
hight quality louis vuitton louis vuitton handbags
if you want to buy louis vuitton bag louis vuitton handbags
high quality and inexpensivelouis vuitton wallets louis vuitton wallets
new arrive louis vuitton purses louis vuitton wallets
Large numbers oflouis vuitton wallets louis vuitton wallets
discount louis vuitton handbags on sale
fashion replica louis vuitton on sale
looking for louis vuitton purses on sale

------
large numbers oflouis vuitton handbagson sale
high quality louis vuitton bagsfor discount
A lot oflouis vuitton walletsfor sale
go to buy louis vuitton handbags
many louis vuitton handbags on sale
I want to buy louis vuitton wallets on sale
looking for louis vuitton purses for sale
Now let's start to see how many types louis vuitton
good qualitylouis vuitton 2010for wholesale
If you want to buyreplica louis vuittonfor discuont
Nowadays replica lvgive you the best choose
If you want to buy good quality of louis vuittonplease choose us
our shop have large numbers ofreplica louis vuittonfor discount
I think you need to have louis vuitton pursesfor sale
Now let's start to see how many types of louis vuitton wallets
Have a stylish Mens Watchesis every man's dream
to have a Hamilton Watcheswill give you more confidence
large numbers of quality Cheap Watchesfor you
if you want to buyCheap Watches for saleplease choose us
large numbers of ladies Watchesfor sale
high quality ofmen's Watchesfor discount
if you want to buy Watches
a great deal ofWatches for sale
------

diffenent kinds of Christian Louboutinfor women
to have a pair ofChristian Louboutin shoesis every woman's dream
A pair of Christian Louboutin bootsbecoming more comfortable
there are many kinds of fashion miu miubags in our shop
to have a miumiufor discount
if you want to buy miu miu handbagfor wholesale
high quality and inexpensivemiu miu baggive you more choice
Now let's start to see how many types ofmiu miufor choice
New Arrival miuon sale
choose miu miu bagyou will find what you need
we offer different kinds of miu miu bags
choose miu miu handbagfor sale
all kind of guccifor sale
if you want to buy replica guccion sale
large quality but unexpensive gucci handbagsfor you
looking for gucci shoesgucci shoes
you need wholesale gucciwholesale gucci
choose China wholesaleyou will find what you need
there are many wholesalefor wholesale
huimin201007

Watches    By Anonymous on Thursday, July 29, 2010
Given that many would choose to wear Replica Watches and Fake Watches, you may take one more step further to be better than them. A Rolex Watches is such a thing that can bring you one more step ahead of your competitors. Rolex Watches, Replica rolex watches, Franck Muller Watches, Hublot Watches, you can't even have not heard of them if you are determined to succeed in the business world. These brand name IWC Watches are symbol of success. You will certainly shine wearing such Longines Watches. However, these Omega Watches are all with hefty price tag. Maybe you need to save money for several months to buy one. Time is precious. Opportunities never waits. And it's miserable to save money for so long to only get a Panerai Watches. Actually there is an easy alternative - buy a replica Patek Philippe Watches.

UGG Classic Tall Boots    By Anonymous on Thursday, July 29, 2010
UGG Upside Boots
Classic Short 5825
Blue Serenity GHD IV Styler
Gucci outlet&Gucci handbags&discount Gucci handbags
UGG Classic Tall Boots


Title:
Comment:
Add Comment   Cancel 
   

Copyright 2009 Aid-IT Solutions   Terms Of Use  Privacy Statement  Sitemap